Who’s Brave Enough to Tell You You’re Wrong?

Imagine being one of the most successful creative talents in the world.

You’ve built an extraordinary reputation. Your work is admired by millions. People look to you for inspiration, direction and the next big idea.

Who would you trust to tell you that your latest idea wasn’t good enough?

The Beatles first met producer George Martin in 1962; four young musicians from Liverpool with enormous ambition, considerable talent and relatively little recording experience.

Martin was a classically trained musician and an experienced record producer.  He understood arrangements, orchestration, recording techniques and the possibilities of a studio in ways that the young band had yet to discover.

However, what made their relationship extraordinary wasn’t simply the knowledge he brought.

It was the way he used it.

Martin wasn’t there just to record whatever The Beatles wanted to play.

He contributed ideas, questioned arrangements, suggested changes and helped them explore possibilities they might not otherwise have considered.

Of course, Martin didn’t write the songs. And he wasn’t responsible for the extraordinary creative talent that Lennon, McCartney, Harrison and Starr brought to the studio.

Instead he provided something that became increasingly valuable as their ambitions developed.

A different perspective.

And, importantly, the confidence to challenge their thinking.

As The Beatles became more successful, that relationship evolved into one of the most celebrated creative collaborations in music.

The band remained responsible for its artistic direction.

Martin helped them explore, question and develop what was possible.

He didn’t need to be the most talented person in the room to make the people around him better.

And I think there’s an important lesson in that for anyone running a business.

Because the more successful you become, the harder it can be to find someone genuinely willing to tell you that you might be wrong.

Success can make challenge disappear

One of the more subtle problems facing successful founders is that their position within the business changes over time.

In the early years, they’re often surrounded by people who are happy to question their ideas.

They may have co-founders, early employees, friends or advisers who are comfortable offering an opinion.

The business is still developing. Nothing is particularly established. Ideas are debated, challenged and changed almost daily.

However, as the business grows, the founder increasingly becomes the person everyone looks to for direction as:

  • They built the company
  • They understand its history
  • They’ve made the decisions that brought it this far.

And so, quite naturally, their opinions carry considerable weight.

The problem is that this can gradually change how other people behave around them:

  • Employees may become reluctant to disagree
  • Managers may present recommendations they believe the founder wants to hear
  • Advisers may focus on answering the questions they’ve been asked rather than challenging whether they’re the right questions.

None of this necessarily happens because the founder is arrogant or unwilling to listen.  Often, quite the opposite.

Many founders genuinely welcome alternative opinions.

However, welcoming challenge and creating an environment where people feel comfortable providing it are two different things.

You can be surrounded by people offering advice and still have nobody genuinely challenging your thinking.

And the more significant the decisions become, the more dangerous that gap can be.

When the person in charge isn’t the person being challenged

As I write this, Manchester United have just announced the dismissal of Michael Carrick.

Another attempt to turn around one of the world’s most recognisable football clubs.

Carrick had taken interim charge in January 2026, overseen a remarkable improvement in results and earned a permanent appointment this summer.  Now, in November 2026, he’s out.

It’s not difficult to understand why the club felt something needed to change, with United struggling near the bottom of the Premier League. 

But there’s a question I find much more interesting than whether Carrick deserved to lose his job.

What if the manager isn’t the only problem?

Manchester United have changed managers repeatedly since Sir Alex Ferguson retired in 2013.

Different personalities. Different playing philosophies. Different approaches to recruitment and team management.

Yet despite those changes, the club has struggled to restore the sustained success it enjoyed under Ferguson.

Of course, individual managers must accept responsibility for their performances.

But when an organisation repeatedly changes the person responsible for delivering results, surely there comes a point when those making the appointments must subject their own decisions to equally rigorous scrutiny?

Perhaps most uncomfortably:

What if the decisions we’re making at the top are contributing to the very problems we’re asking someone else to fix?

I am not privy to the conversations that take place behind closed doors at Old Trafford, but from the outside, the recurring cycle of managerial changes raises an important question about organisational accountability.

And it’s one that applies just as readily to a business founder.

  • If you’ve changed sales managers three times without improving revenue, have you properly challenged your commercial strategy?
  • If different teams keep encountering the same operational problems, have you examined the structure and expectations you’ve created?

Sometimes the most important change is in the thinking of the person making those decisions.

The best leaders don’t simply surround themselves with people they can hold accountable.

They surround themselves with people who are prepared to hold their thinking accountable too.

Advice, agreement and challenge are not the same thing

I think it’s worth distinguishing between three different things that often get confused.

Agreement is when someone tells you that your proposed course of action sounds sensible.

There’s nothing inherently wrong with agreement, but agreement on its own doesn’t tell you very much about the quality of your thinking.

Advice is when someone offers their opinion about what you should do.

That can be extremely valuable, particularly when it comes from someone with experience or expertise you don’t possess.

However, advice can also have limitations as it may reflect someone else’s priorities, assumptions or experience.

And it doesn’t necessarily mean they’ve fully understood what you’re trying to achieve.

Challenge is something different.

Challenge is when someone helps you examine whether the reasoning behind your decision is sufficiently robust.

They don’t necessarily tell you what to do.  They ask whether you’ve properly understood the problem.

Whether the assumptions are reasonable.  Whether you’ve considered the alternatives.

And whether the evidence genuinely supports the conclusion you’re reaching.

Example: imagine telling someone that you intend to recruit another senior employee.

Agreement sounds like: “That makes sense. You’ve been busy for months.”

Advice sounds like: “I think you should recruit someone with more commercial experience.”

Challenge sounds like: “What evidence tells us that another employee is the solution to the problem you’re trying to solve?”

That last question might lead to a very different conversation.

Perhaps you do need another employee, but perhaps the real problem is pricing, productivity, customer profitability or the way existing resources are being managed.

The person challenging you isn’t necessarily opposing the decision.

They’re helping you understand whether you’re making it for the right reasons.

And that’s a very different contribution.

The value isn’t in having someone make the decision for you. It’s in improving the quality of the decision you’re able to make.

Why genuine challenge requires something from both sides

The person offering it needs the confidence to ask difficult questions.

They need sufficient understanding of the business to make those questions relevant.

And they need to be prepared to say something the founder may not particularly want to hear.

Perhaps the numbers are perfectly sound, but the proposed decision doesn’t appear consistent with what the founder says they want from the business.

Those aren’t always comfortable conversations, but they’re often the most valuable ones.

Good challenge has to begin with an understanding of what success actually means to the person making the decision.

Otherwise, we’re simply substituting someone else’s judgement for our own.

Equally, the founder has a responsibility.

To invite challenge before becoming too committed to an outcome.

To distinguish disagreement from disloyalty.

To be prepared to change their mind when the evidence warrants it.

And to recognise that asking for another perspective isn’t a sign of uncertainty or weakness.

It’s a way of improving judgement.

Of course, there’s a balance.

Challenge shouldn’t become an excuse for endless analysis.

Nor should every important decision require unanimous agreement.

At some point, the discussion has to end and someone has to take responsibility for the choice.

That brings us back to last week’s article.

The decisions that shape your business may ultimately be yours to make, but that doesn’t mean every assumption behind those decisions should go unchallenged.

Who is in your corner?

As we approach the end of the year and begin thinking about plans for 2027, I think there’s a useful exercise every founder could undertake.

Consider the people you turn to when making an important business decision.

Then ask yourself three questions.

1. Who can genuinely tell me I’m wrong?

Not simply someone who occasionally disagrees.  Someone whose judgement you respect and who feels comfortable challenging your thinking, even when they know you have a strong opinion.

2. Who understands enough about my business to make that challenge useful?

Do they understand your commercial model, financial performance, ambitions and constraints?

And importantly, do they understand what you’re actually trying to achieve?

3. When did I last change my mind because someone challenged my thinking?

This is perhaps the most revealing question of all.

If you can’t remember, it might be worth asking why.

Are your decisions consistently well supported?

Or have you gradually surrounded yourself with people who have become more comfortable agreeing than questioning?

There isn’t necessarily an easy answer, but I suspect the exercise is worth undertaking.

The person willing to ask the difficult question

When we look back at The Beatles, it’s easy to focus on the music they created.

However, their relationship with George Martin offers another lesson.

Exceptional talent doesn’t eliminate the value of another perspective.

And success doesn’t mean you’ve reached the point where your thinking no longer benefits from challenge.

If anything, the opposite may be true.

As your business becomes more successful, the decisions become more consequential.

You don’t necessarily need someone who tells you what to do.

You certainly don’t need someone who agrees with everything you say.

You need people who understand what you’re trying to achieve, care about the outcome and are willing to ask the questions you might prefer not to hear.

Yes, ultimately, the responsibility for the decision may still rest with you, but being responsible for the decision doesn’t mean you have to be alone in making it.

And sometimes, the most valuable person in the room isn’t the one with the answers.

It’s the one willing to ask the question nobody else will.

Helping leaders and businesses drive success forward

Here at Nuvem9, we do things a bit differently – we’re not your traditional accountants or financial advisors.

We empower ambitious business owners to grow with clarity and confidence. Based in the UK, we specialise in working in creative and service-led industries that demand a financial partner who gets it — responsive, knowledgeable and always easy to talk to.

Whether you’re scaling up, navigating change, or just need someone who speaks your language, we bring experienced financial and commercial advice and proactive support that keeps your finances clear, compliant, and under control. No jargon. No delays. Just sharp insights and a team who’s got your back.

Want to see if we could be a fit for your business? Let’s connect virtually (we’ll be live, no robots here).

Knowledge: Finance for Creative Studios

Subscribe to our Newsletter